On June 9, 2025, the Maui County Housing and Land Use Committee convened to discuss critical issues surrounding short-term rentals (STRs) and their impact on the local housing market. The meeting featured passionate testimonies from residents, particularly those involved in the STR sector, who voiced strong opposition to proposed legislation aimed at phasing out short-term rentals in certain areas, including Wailea.

Cara Burkholtz, a resident and STR owner, articulated concerns that the proposed bill would not effectively address the affordable housing crisis in Maui. She argued that the legislation could lead to increased lawsuits and financial burdens on the county, diverting resources away from building long-term affordable housing. Burkholtz emphasized that many properties, including her own, were originally designated for short-term rental use, and changing this status could lead to significant financial losses for owners who rely on STR income.

Jennifer Taylor, secretary of the Palms at Wailea, echoed Burkholtz's sentiments, highlighting the economic implications of reducing STR availability in Wailea. She pointed out that the area was developed as a resort community, with a significant portion of its economy reliant on tourism. Taylor warned that limiting STRs would not only reduce visitor numbers but also negatively impact local businesses that depend on tourist spending.

The discussions underscored a broader tension in Maui County between the need for affordable housing and the economic benefits of maintaining a robust tourism sector. Residents expressed a desire for solutions that would not only preserve their livelihoods but also ensure that affordable housing remains a priority for the community.

As the committee continues to deliberate on the proposed legislation, the testimonies from Burkholtz and Taylor reflect the complexities of balancing housing needs with economic realities in Maui. The outcome of these discussions will likely have lasting implications for both residents and the local economy, as the county navigates the challenges of housing affordability and tourism management.