The Maui County Housing and Land Use Committee convened on June 9, 2025, to discuss pressing issues surrounding housing and rental policies in the wake of recent challenges faced by the community. The meeting featured a series of testimonies from residents and stakeholders, highlighting the complexities of the housing market and the impact of proposed legislation.

The session began with a discussion on the potential influx of new residents to Maui, particularly retirees and remote workers from high-cost areas like San Francisco and New York. A committee member raised concerns about the feasibility of housing for families, citing high rental prices for oceanfront condos, which can reach $4,600. This sentiment was echoed by a testifier, who shared personal experiences of homelessness following the Lahaina fire and the struggle to afford rental prices.

Testimonies continued with Donna Butterfield, who questioned the community's ability to vote on housing policies, drawing parallels to past successful initiatives like the plastic bag ban. She expressed concern that the proposed legislation could send a negative message about tourism, which is vital to Maui's economy. Butterfield advocated for a pause on new hotel developments and suggested that the county explore options for affordable workforce housing, referencing successful models in other states.

The discussion also touched on the implications of Bill 9, which does not ban all short-term rentals but restricts them in certain zones. Butterfield clarified her position, emphasizing the need for a balanced approach that considers the existing rental market and the potential consequences of strict regulations.

Francine Johansson, another testifier, voiced her opposition to the bill, stating that the statistics presented by the mayor did not fully capture the nuances of the housing crisis. She urged the committee to consider the broader implications of their decisions on the community's economy and housing availability.

As the meeting progressed, committee members engaged with the testimonies, seeking clarification on various points raised. The session underscored the ongoing challenges in Maui's housing landscape, with a clear call for more comprehensive discussions and solutions that address the needs of both residents and the local economy.

The committee plans to continue its discussions and explore potential next steps in addressing the housing crisis, emphasizing the importance of community input and collaboration in shaping effective policies.