The McKinney Historic Preservation Advisory Board convened on June 5, 2025, to discuss proposed changes to a historic home in the area. The meeting focused on updated architectural plans that included significant alterations to the roofline, specifically the addition of larger dormers.

During the presentation, staff highlighted that the proposed changes did not align with the Secretary of the Interior's standards for historic preservation. The staff recommended approval of the certificate of appropriateness with conditions, notably the removal of the two proposed shed dormers. They argued that these alterations would compromise the historic character of the property, which is essential for maintaining the integrity of the neighborhood.

Board members raised questions about the functionality of the existing second floor, which currently includes limited usable space. The homeowners expressed a desire to expand the upstairs area to create more livable space, including adding a bedroom and a bathroom. However, the staff reiterated that any significant changes would likely alter the historic integrity of the structure, which is a primary concern for preservation efforts.

The discussion also touched on the existing materials of the home, with the homeowners indicating they would use similar siding to maintain consistency with the original design. Additionally, a question was raised regarding a Victorian-style fence that was visible in older photographs but not present during the meeting.

As the meeting concluded, the board members considered the implications of their decisions on the home's classification within the historic district. If the proposed changes were approved, it could potentially lower the home's classification from medium to low priority, impacting its historical significance.

The board's deliberations reflect the ongoing challenge of balancing modern needs with the preservation of McKinney's historical character. The next steps will involve further discussions and potential revisions to the proposed plans to find a compromise that respects the home's heritage while accommodating the homeowners' needs.