The Houston Archaeological and Historical Commission convened on June 5, 2025, to discuss a proposed interior remodel of the historic rural painter house. The meeting focused on alterations that include significant changes to the home's interior structure and exterior features.
The applicant's proposal involves demolishing most of the interior walls, removing non-original balconies and porch areas, and altering windows on the west wall to enlarge a shower. Additionally, the plan includes the removal of two previously relocated historic windows and the non-original gable at the west elevation. The remodel aims to replace non-original windows with appropriate wood-clad double-hung windows while ensuring that all original windows are preserved and repaired as necessary.
During the meeting, staff recommended approval of the Certificate of Appropriateness (COA) with specific conditions. Notably, the stained glass windows on the west elevation must remain in their original locations, and while the removal of the second-floor balcony door is permitted, a window cannot be installed in its place. All doors in the original structure must receive staff approval prior to purchase or installation.
Commissioner Couch raised a concern regarding the window pattern in the addition, suggesting that it should feature a 1 over 1 design instead of the proposed 9 over 1 or 12 over 1 patterns. This suggestion aimed to maintain historical accuracy without being overly literal in replicating the original design.
Public comments included insights from Yacinta Fenerdi, representing the residential design office, who expressed willingness to adjust the window designs to meet the commission's preferences. Another speaker highlighted that the stained glass window in question was originally a door, suggesting that its removal would not compromise the home's historical integrity.
The discussion concluded with a consensus that further investigation into the historical context of the stained glass window was necessary. The commission agreed to allow staff to address this issue further, indicating a collaborative approach to preserving the home's historical significance while accommodating the homeowner's desires.
The meeting underscored the balance between maintaining historical integrity and adapting to modern needs, with the commission committed to ensuring that any alterations respect the house's heritage. Further actions will be determined as staff continues to evaluate the proposed changes.