The Galveston Landmark Commission convened on June 2, 2025, to discuss a significant request for a certificate of appropriateness concerning a historic home that recently suffered extensive fire damage. The homeowners, the McCrackens, are seeking approval to replace the exterior wood siding with smooth cement siding and to remove two non-functional brick chimneys as part of their restoration efforts.

The request comes after a fire that highlighted the need for improved fire resistance in the home. The McCrackens and their contractor, Alex Gonzales, emphasized that the proposed fiber cement siding would provide better fire protection compared to traditional wood siding, which is more susceptible to flames. They also plan to install a sprinkler system to further enhance safety.

During the meeting, staff noted that while the design standards for historic properties typically favor the preservation of original materials, there is some flexibility for less visible areas of the home. The staff report indicated that the proposed cement siding on the sides and rear of the house partially conforms to these standards, but recommended retaining wood siding on the front facade to maintain the historic character.

Public comments during the hearing reflected a strong community interest in the McCrackens' plight. Neighbors expressed support for the proposed changes, citing the importance of fire safety in densely built areas where homes are in close proximity. The McCrackens highlighted the historical significance of their home and their commitment to preserving its architectural integrity while adapting to modern safety standards.

The commission ultimately recommended approval of the request with specific conditions, balancing the need for historical preservation with the practical considerations of fire safety and structural integrity. The decision underscores the ongoing dialogue in Galveston about how to protect historic properties while ensuring the safety and welfare of residents. As the city moves forward, the implications of this case may influence future discussions on building materials and fire safety regulations in historic districts.