Milwaukee committee rejects Moxie Hotel plan citing community development concerns

The City of Milwaukee's Zoning, Neighborhoods & Development Committee convened on May 28, 2025, to discuss significant developments, including the proposed Moxie Hotel project. The meeting highlighted concerns regarding labor agreements, community benefits, and the overall economic impact of the project on the city.

A key topic of discussion was the status of the Responsible Public Policy (RPP) and Project Labor Agreements (PLA) related to the Moxie Hotel. Committee members questioned whether these agreements were formalized in writing or based on past practices. It was clarified that while discussions were ongoing, no formal agreements had been established yet. The committee emphasized the importance of ensuring that labor considerations are addressed in future contracts.

Public testimony featured a range of opinions on the Moxie Hotel proposal. Dan Bukavich, president of the Milwaukee Building and Construction Trades Council, expressed support for the project, highlighting its potential to create jobs and meet RPP goals, which include 40% participation from underrepresented groups. He stressed the importance of establishing a project labor agreement once the project is approved.

Conversely, several community members, including economists and union representatives, urged the committee to reject the Moxie proposal, arguing that it does not represent the highest and best use of the valuable downtown site. They pointed out that a larger hotel could generate more tax revenue and employment opportunities, which are crucial for addressing economic disparities in the city. Concerns were raised about the project's potential to underperform compared to other developments in the area, particularly given the significant public investment already made in the Deer District.

The committee also discussed the timeline for the project, with developers indicating a goal to commence construction by July 2026, contingent on securing financing and approvals. However, the lack of a finalized financing plan raised questions about the project's feasibility.

In conclusion, the meeting underscored the ongoing debate over the Moxie Hotel project, balancing the need for development with the community's desire for equitable economic growth and job creation. The committee's next steps will involve further deliberation on the proposal and its implications for Milwaukee's future development landscape.