Design team discusses sunken courtyards for College Avenue development project

The Ithaca City Planning Board meeting on May 27, 2025, sparked a lively debate over the design of proposed sunken courtyards in a new development project. Board members expressed mixed feelings about the concept, weighing the potential benefits against concerns about accessibility and aesthetics.

The discussion began with a proposal to set back the top floor of the building by two feet, which some members felt could enhance the design. However, the focus quickly shifted to the sunken courtyards, with one member initiating a straw poll to gauge the board's interest in pursuing the idea further. The courtyards are intended to create dynamic, engaging spaces that would enhance the streetscape along College Avenue, but several board members voiced apprehensions about their practicality.

Concerns were raised about the challenges of maintaining accessibility in these sunken areas, with one member noting that making the courtyards accessible could compromise their design and functionality. Another member highlighted the potential for these spaces to become undesirable, citing issues like trash collection and safety due to their depth.

Despite the reservations, some board members saw merit in the courtyards, arguing they could add vibrancy and interest to the neighborhood. One member emphasized the importance of creating public and private outdoor spaces that balance community needs with residential privacy.

As the meeting progressed, it became clear that further exploration of the design was necessary. Board members agreed to revisit the topic in future discussions, focusing on detailed design elements and the overall impact on the streetscape. The outcome of this debate will play a crucial role in shaping the character of the development and its integration into the Ithaca community.