The Virgin Islands Legislature's Committee on Health, Hospitals, and Human Services convened on May 27, 2025, to discuss significant updates to the fine structure for environmental health violations, particularly focusing on grease trap regulations. The meeting highlighted the need for a more consistent and objective penalty system to address violations that pose health risks to the community.

Currently, the fine for a first grease trap violation is set at $30, with subsequent offenses carrying fines of $50. However, proposed amendments could increase the maximum fine for a first offense to $900, with higher penalties for repeat violations. This change aims to deter businesses from neglecting health regulations and to ensure compliance with safety standards.

Assistant Commissioner Ruben Molloy emphasized the importance of a clear and documented fee structure to avoid discrepancies in fines imposed by inspectors. The committee discussed the necessity of a risk-based inspection approach, which focuses on the potential health risks associated with violations rather than arbitrary penalties. This method aims to improve public health outcomes by holding businesses accountable for serious infractions while allowing for educational opportunities to help them comply with regulations.

Several committee members expressed concerns about the potential financial burden on businesses, particularly smaller establishments. They advocated for a balanced approach that would penalize repeat offenders without disproportionately impacting responsible business owners. The discussion included suggestions for a tiered fine system that would gradually increase penalties based on the severity and frequency of violations.

The committee also addressed the need for transparency and fairness in the enforcement of health regulations, with members calling for a standardized penalty schedule to prevent arbitrary fines. The overarching goal remains to protect public health while ensuring that businesses have the opportunity to rectify violations before facing severe penalties.

As the committee moves forward, it is clear that the proposed changes to the fine structure are intended to modernize the enforcement of health regulations in the Virgin Islands, aligning them with national standards and ultimately improving community health outcomes. The next steps will involve drafting a comprehensive fee schedule that reflects these discussions and addresses the concerns raised by both legislators and health officials.