The Design Review Board (DRB) of Knoxville convened on May 25, 2025, to discuss several key agenda items, primarily focusing on signage and architectural modifications within the city’s historic districts.

The meeting commenced with a review of an unilluminated projecting sign located at 2303 Adair Avenue, where the applicant expanded the footprint of an existing porch into a half-length front porch. Following this, the board addressed the first significant item on the agenda concerning a proposed sign at 500 South Gay Street.

The proposal involved the installation of a new non-illuminated sign face on an existing rooftop sign measuring approximately 5.65 square feet. However, the board noted that new rooftop signs are prohibited under city sign code, and the existing sign had been classified as an abandoned non-conforming sign. The applicant, represented by Tony Sapples of Neon Service, argued that the sign was eligible for refacing, as it had been previously established before the current regulations.

During the discussion, board members expressed concerns regarding the proposed design, which they felt resembled a temporary billboard rather than a sign that would contribute positively to the historic character of downtown Knoxville. Members emphasized the importance of maintaining the aesthetic integrity of the area, suggesting that the design should reflect a more traditional style compatible with the historic context.

After deliberation, the board unanimously agreed to postpone the decision, allowing the applicant to revise the design to better align with the board's recommendations. The motion to postpone was carried, with the expectation that the applicant would return with a proposal that not only addresses size but also enhances the visual character of the sign.

The meeting then moved on to the next agenda item concerning 420 Clinch Avenue, indicating a continued focus on maintaining the historic integrity of Knoxville's architectural landscape. The board's commitment to preserving the character of the city was evident throughout the discussions, highlighting the ongoing challenges of balancing modern business needs with historical preservation.