Cheyenne City Council debates necessity of updating outdated comprehensive plan

During the recent Committee of the Whole meeting on May 21, 2025, the Cheyenne City Council engaged in a heated discussion regarding the necessity and funding of the city's comprehensive plan, also known as the master plan. The debate centered around the potential allocation of nearly $250,000 for a new document, which some council members deemed unnecessary given the existing plan's age and the possibility of simply updating its elements.

Councilwoman Aldridge raised concerns about the outdated nature of the current plan, established in 2014, questioning its relevance and the city's obligation to adhere to its guidelines. Director Blum acknowledged that while the city is required to have a master plan, the specifics of its implementation can be flexible. He noted that certain outdated recommendations, such as converting residential properties along arterial streets into commercial spaces, are not being followed due to changing community needs.

Mayor Collins expressed frustration over the financial burden of continuously funding new plans, suggesting that the city could instead focus on updating existing documents to reflect current demographics and development practices. He emphasized the importance of public input in the planning process, highlighting a lack of community engagement in the current discussions.

The council also discussed the implications of not having an updated comprehensive plan, particularly concerning eligibility for state and federal grants. While some members argued that the outdated plan could hinder grant applications, others pointed out that the impact is uncertain and varies by funding source.

As the council deliberates the future of Cheyenne's comprehensive plan, the conversation underscores a broader issue of balancing fiscal responsibility with the need for effective urban planning. The outcome of this debate could significantly influence the city's development strategy and its ability to secure funding for future projects.