Tensions flared at the Memphis City Council meeting on May 20, 2025, as residents voiced strong opposition to a proposed subdivision championed by Councilman Carlisle. The crux of the debate centered on neighborhood preservation, with local residents expressing their desire to maintain the character of their community.

Corey Grubbs, a resident of Lundy Place, articulated the frustrations of his neighbors, stating that the proposal was primarily driven by Carlisle's financial interests rather than community needs. "This is about neighbors who would like to keep their neighborhood as it is today," Grubbs asserted, highlighting the residents' right to object to the development. He criticized Carlisle for not engaging in discussions or mediation efforts aimed at finding a compromise.

Susan Stevenson, another local resident, echoed these sentiments, urging the council to heed the voices of those living near the proposed site. "As a super majority, they are asking the council to consider their impact on their life in their neighborhood," she emphasized, reinforcing the community's collective stance against the subdivision.

The meeting underscored a growing divide between council members and constituents, with residents feeling sidelined in a process they believe should prioritize their concerns. As discussions continue, the council faces mounting pressure to balance development interests with the wishes of the community. The outcome of this proposal could set a significant precedent for future developments in Memphis.