In a recent meeting of the Nantucket Select Board, a passionate plea was made regarding the repairs to the veil war monument on Upper Main Street. The atmosphere was charged with concern as community members gathered to discuss the integrity of a site that holds deep historical significance.

Rita, a member of the historical commission, presented a picture of the recent repairs, urging the board to reconsider accepting the current state of the work. She highlighted several issues with the new granite post and curbing, which were set taller and wider than the original structures, creating an uneven appearance. The replacement stone, made of berry granite, starkly contrasted with the original Quincy granite, lacking the distinctive dark flecks that characterized the historic material.

Rita recalled advocating for the use of reclaimed historic Quincy granite back in March, a suggestion that was dismissed as unfeasible. However, she emphasized that sourcing such materials is indeed possible, albeit more time-consuming and potentially costly. She expressed concern over the fate of the original stone that was removed during the repairs, questioning whether it was still in the possession of the Department of Public Works.

With a sense of urgency, Rita urged the Select Board to reject what she deemed substandard repairs and to engage with the insurance company overseeing the claim to demand a more appropriate restoration. She also raised questions about the subcontractor selection process, noting that the contractor responsible for the repairs was hired solely by the insurance company without town consultation.

In closing, Rita reminded the board of the monument's significance, urging them to honor the sacrifices of the soldiers and sailors commemorated there with a repair that reflects their legacy. The discussion underscored the community's commitment to preserving its history and ensuring that such landmarks are treated with the respect they deserve. As the meeting concluded, the board was left to ponder the implications of Rita's heartfelt appeal and the future of the monument's restoration.