During the recent Board of Architectural Review meeting in Winchester, Virginia, discussions centered on a proposal to replace aging windows in a historic condominium building. The structure, originally built around 1900 and renovated in 2019, has been facing issues with eight windows dating back to 1986, one of which has reportedly caused significant rot due to leaks.

The property owners presented their case, emphasizing the need to replace the deteriorating windows with new ones that closely match the recently installed black metal-clad windows on the building's rear. The proposed replacements are from the same manufacturer, ensuring aesthetic consistency with the existing renovations. The owners highlighted that the new windows would not only enhance the building's appearance but also address the current issues of water damage and improper flashing.

The board members engaged in a thorough discussion regarding the historical significance of the building and the appropriateness of the proposed materials. They noted that the problematic windows were part of a 1986 addition, which is not considered historically significant. This context allowed for some flexibility in the design guidelines, as the board members recognized the importance of maintaining the building's overall integrity while accommodating necessary updates.

Ultimately, the board expressed a general consensus that the proposed metal-clad windows would be a suitable replacement, aligning with the building's aesthetic and functional needs. The discussion underscored the balance between preserving historical character and addressing modern maintenance challenges in Winchester's architectural landscape. The board is expected to finalize their decision in the coming weeks, paving the way for the much-needed renovations to proceed.