City Council denies sidewalk cafe application for ADA non-compliance on Eighth Avenue

The Manhattan Community Board 2's Outdoor Dining Working Group convened on May 13, 2025, to discuss several key issues surrounding outdoor dining permits and compliance with regulations. The meeting highlighted concerns about accessibility, safety, and the operational practices of local establishments.

A significant topic of discussion was the outdoor dining setup at a café located on Seventh Avenue South. Board members noted that while the café has expanded its space by taking over an adjacent storefront, there are ongoing issues with its outdoor seating arrangement. Specifically, concerns were raised about the lack of clear pathways for pedestrians and the positioning of barriers that obstruct access to tables. Members emphasized the need for a continuous barrier to ensure safety and compliance with regulations, particularly regarding the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA).

Another establishment discussed was Arthur and Sons, located at 34 Eighth Avenue. The board expressed confusion over the business's licensing status, as there appeared to be discrepancies in the ownership and operational details. Members pointed out that the application for outdoor dining lacked clarity, particularly regarding the business's connection to a previous entity, Amphora. The board voted to conditionally deny the sidewalk café application due to ADA compliance issues and the unclear status of the business's liquor license.

The meeting concluded with a decision to deny the outdoor dining applications for both the café on Seventh Avenue and Arthur and Sons, pending further clarification and compliance with city regulations. The board's actions reflect a commitment to ensuring that outdoor dining spaces are accessible and safe for all patrons while adhering to the necessary legal frameworks.