Lake Forest Planning Commission reviews Caspian Restaurant's hookah lounge permit request

A heated debate unfolded at the Lake Forest Planning Commission meeting on May 8, 2025, as community members voiced their opinions on a proposed permit for Caspian Restaurant to serve hookah. The discussion highlighted a clash between cultural appreciation and community concerns over noise and secondhand smoke.

Caspian Restaurant, a local establishment known for its Persian cuisine, is seeking approval to offer hookah as part of its dining experience. Supporters, including attorney Lawrence Hudak, argued that the restaurant has been a valued community member for 30 years and that the noise levels from the patio are within acceptable limits. Hudak emphasized that sound tests showed noise levels significantly lower than what residents reported, asserting that the restaurant's outdoor setup, including walls and trellises, effectively mitigates sound.

Malika Malali, a resident and supporter of Caspian, echoed these sentiments, describing the restaurant as a cultural hub that fosters community connections. She dismissed claims of disruptive noise and smoke, stating that many objections stem from misunderstandings about hookah culture.

However, opposition was strong among several residents living directly across from the restaurant. Jessica Valenzuela, a mother of young children, expressed her concerns about noise disrupting her family's peace and the potential health risks of secondhand smoke. Nicole Bursick, another resident, shared her experiences with noise disturbances, particularly during recent events, and questioned the appropriateness of an outdoor hookah lounge in a residential area.

Catherine Otis, also opposing the permit, called for an acoustical study to assess noise levels during peak hours before any decisions are made. She highlighted the ongoing issues with noise from the restaurant, even with windows closed.

As the meeting concluded, the Planning Commission faced the challenge of balancing cultural offerings with the well-being of local residents. The outcome of this permit request remains uncertain, with further discussions anticipated in future meetings.