The Gallatin City Planning Commission convened on May 6, 2025, to discuss significant community concerns regarding a proposed marina project that has drawn considerable opposition from local residents. The meeting highlighted the stark contrast between the original marina plan presented in 2007 and the current proposal, which has expanded dramatically in scope.

Initially, the plan included a modest marina with fewer than 75 boat slips. However, the revised proposal now features over 400 boat slips, a large dry dock, a restaurant, a store, and a fueling station, transforming it into a major destination accessible by both boat and car. Residents expressed fears that this development would not only disrupt the natural beauty of Old Hickory Lake but also lead to increased boat traffic, security issues, and a decline in property values.

Community members voiced their concerns during the meeting, emphasizing the potential negative impacts on traffic congestion, particularly on Nashville Pike, and the accessibility of emergency services for neighborhoods like Douglas Bend. Mike Schulte, a resident and local leader, reported that over 1,466 households had signed a petition opposing the project, reflecting widespread discontent among the community. He noted that a public meeting held in April attracted over 400 attendees, far exceeding expectations, and underscored the strong opposition to the marina's expansion.

Residents also criticized the developer's approach, alleging threats and intimidation tactics when community members raised concerns about the project. They called for a traffic study to assess the impact on local roads and emergency access, as well as a return to the original marina plan that would better align with the community's character and needs.

Joe Slavic, another resident, echoed these sentiments, describing the current proposal as "egregious" and significantly larger than what was initially promised. He raised concerns about the aesthetic implications of the dry dock and the potential for increased boat traffic to compromise safety and recreational use of the lake.

The meeting concluded with a clear message from residents: they seek a marina that respects the original vision and serves the community's interests without overwhelming the local environment or infrastructure. The Planning Commission is expected to consider these concerns as they move forward with discussions on the marina project.