Investigator exposes flaws in Pamela Vitale murder case against Scott DeLeschi

During the recent Lafayette City Council meeting, community members voiced urgent concerns regarding the unresolved murder case of Pamela Vitale, which dates back to February 2005. The discussions centered around allegations of wrongful conviction and calls for justice for Scott Doleski, who has spent nearly two decades in prison for a crime many believe he did not commit.

Former insurance investigator and advocate for Doleski, who spoke passionately at the meeting, asserted that the real perpetrator is Vitale's husband, Daniel Horowitz. He criticized the initial investigation and the handling of evidence, claiming that critical DNA analysis was mishandled and that Horowitz's behavior following the murder raised suspicions. The speaker emphasized that Horowitz's media presence and lack of a solid alibi during the time of the murder should have prompted further scrutiny.

Another speaker, Ralph Fernandez, a private investigator and former police officer, echoed these sentiments, stating that Doleski was unfairly targeted due to his socioeconomic status. He urged the council to take action to ensure that the true murderer is brought to justice, highlighting the need for a new trial for Doleski to reveal the evidence that was overlooked in the original case.

The emotional testimonies from community members underscored a growing frustration with the perceived inaction from local authorities regarding the case. Many expressed concern for public safety, suggesting that the real killer remains at large, posing a threat to the community.

In addition to the discussions surrounding the Vitale case, resident Sheila Castilla addressed the importance of free speech, emphasizing that citizens should have the right to express their opinions peacefully. This call for open dialogue reflects a broader desire among residents to engage with local governance on pressing issues.

As the meeting concluded, it was clear that the unresolved murder case continues to weigh heavily on the community, with advocates urging city officials to take a more active role in seeking justice for Scott Doleski and ensuring accountability for the crime that has left a lasting impact on Lafayette.