Carmel Board of Zoning Appeals renews short term rental exception for Cadanas property

The Board of Zoning Appeals meeting held on April 28, 2025, in Carmel, Indiana, focused on the review and approval of short-term rental petitions. The meeting began with a discussion on the regulations governing short-term rentals, emphasizing the importance of compliance with city ordinances. Planning staff confirmed that the Carmel Code Enforcement Department had no issues with the property in question and recommended approval of the petition, noting that any granted exception would be valid for only one year, after which reapproval would be necessary.

The first petition discussed involved a short-term rental request, which had undergone thorough reviews by the Department of Community Services and the engineering department. The board reiterated that adherence to established regulations is crucial for favorable determinations. The petitioner was reminded to maintain good conduct, as complaints from neighbors could jeopardize future approvals.

Following this, Mike Cadanas, representing his wife Karen, sought a renewal of their short-term rental exception. He reported no complaints or issues during their rental period. Support for the renewal was voiced by a neighbor, Marty Carey, who praised the respectful behavior of renters and confirmed that there had been no problems over the years.

The department's report reiterated that the renewal application for the short-term residential rental was entitled to favorable consideration, as there had been no complaints or violations reported in the past year. With no opposition to the petition, the board moved forward with the approval process.

In conclusion, the meeting underscored the city's commitment to regulating short-term rentals while ensuring compliance with local ordinances. The board's decisions reflect a structured approach to maintaining community standards and addressing the needs of both property owners and residents.