Santa Cruz residents urge planning commission to reconsider downtown expansion plan

The Santa Cruz City Planning Commission meeting on April 17, 2025, sparked significant community concern regarding the proposed downtown expansion plan, particularly its potential impact on the city's character and housing affordability. Residents voiced their apprehensions about the plan's implications for Santa Cruz's identity, traffic congestion, and the local workforce.

Paula Castagna, a homeowner from the Seabright area, emphasized the need for careful consideration of the plan, warning that the proposed 12-story buildings could threaten the unique spirit of Santa Cruz. She highlighted the current traffic gridlock and questioned the feasibility of encouraging walking or biking in light of ongoing construction projects. Castagna also raised concerns about the lack of affordable rental options, noting that many new developments appear to cater primarily to high-income renters.

Local carpenter Alberto Lustre echoed these sentiments, stressing the absence of labor considerations in the planning documents. He urged the commission to prioritize local hiring and apprenticeship opportunities for youth, arguing that the current plans do not adequately support the local workforce. His call for a partnership with local labor was supported by Brian Shields, a senior organizer for the carpenters' union, who pointed out the need for living wages and compliance with labor standards in new developments.

Concerns about the proposed plan's transparency were also raised. Resident Bruce Thomas questioned the commission's assurances that building heights would not exceed 12 stories, citing previous instances where developers received waivers. He called for clarification on the plan's provisions regarding floor area ratios (FAR), which could allow for taller buildings than anticipated.

As the meeting concluded, it was clear that residents are seeking a more inclusive approach to urban development—one that considers not only the physical structures but also the community's needs and values. The discussions highlighted a growing demand for affordable housing, local job opportunities, and a commitment to preserving the character of Santa Cruz as the city navigates its future growth. The commission's next steps will be crucial in addressing these community concerns and ensuring that development aligns with the values of its residents.