The Florida Legislature's Committee on Ethics and Elections convened on April 22, 2025, to discuss the nomination of Adam Kissel to the University of West Florida (UWF) Board of Trustees. The meeting highlighted a significant divide among committee members and stakeholders regarding Kissel's suitability for the position.

Dr. Judith Benz, president emeritus of UWF, expressed strong reservations about Kissel's nomination. She emphasized the importance of trust in university governance and raised concerns about Kissel's lack of experience within the university system. Benz argued that Kissel's appointment could impose an ideological shift that may not align with the university's mission and values. She urged the committee to consider the perspectives of those within the UWF community who feel uneasy about Kissel's potential influence.

In contrast, supporters of Kissel, including Senators Collins and Groll, defended his nomination. They highlighted his openness about his views and his potential to bring valuable insights, particularly regarding accreditation issues. They argued that a diverse board with varied opinions is essential for the university's growth and effectiveness.

Despite the support from some committee members, the nomination faced significant opposition. Ultimately, the committee voted against Kissel's confirmation, with a tally of 5 votes in favor and 3 against. As a result, Kissel's name will not be forwarded to the Senate for further consideration.

The meeting underscored the ongoing debates surrounding governance in Florida's educational institutions, reflecting broader tensions over educational policy and leadership. The committee's decision marks a pivotal moment for UWF as it navigates its future direction amidst differing viewpoints on governance and trust.