Owner seeks approval for extensive rehabilitation of historic home at 66 Saragossa Street

The Historic Architectural Review Board (HARB) of St. Augustine has approved significant renovations for a historic property at 66 Saragossa Street, marking a pivotal step in its preservation efforts. The board's decision, made during their April 17, 2025 meeting, allows the new owners to proceed with extensive rehabilitation work aimed at restoring the home while adhering to historical preservation standards.

The property, which faced potential demolition due to severe structural issues, has undergone an elevation to meet FEMA flood requirements and to address extensive damage to its foundation. The new owners have committed to preserving the home's historical integrity while making necessary updates. They plan to replace deteriorated wooden members and restore windows wherever possible, ensuring that any new materials used will be compatible with the Secretary of the Interior's Standards for Rehabilitation.

Key aspects of the renovation include the removal of a deteriorating kitchen addition and the reconstruction of a safer stairway to the second floor. The owners also intend to add a rear wing to the house, expanding its footprint by approximately 400 square feet to accommodate a master bedroom. While the primary structure will retain its original wood siding, discussions are underway regarding the use of alternative materials for the new addition to manage costs effectively.

The board expressed strong support for the project, highlighting the owners' dedication to preserving the property’s historical character. Members noted the importance of documenting any changes to historic materials and encouraged the owners to maintain open communication with staff regarding material choices as the project progresses.

As the renovation moves forward, the owners are optimistic about revitalizing the property and contributing to the community's historical landscape. The board's approval not only facilitates the restoration of this specific home but also reinforces St. Augustine's commitment to preserving its rich architectural heritage.