The St. Augustine City Commission convened on April 14, 2025, to discuss a significant legal matter involving a settlement proposal related to a lawsuit concerning land ownership and dock construction on Hospital Creek. The meeting began with a roll call and a brief public comment period, which saw no participation from residents.

City Attorney Isabel Lopez introduced the settlement opportunity regarding the case of Marlow v. City of St. Augustine, which has been ongoing for several years. The lawsuit involves a private party asserting claims over certain areas of land that overlap with the city’s public land. The plaintiff seeks to build a dock, similar to those of neighboring properties, which would require permits from the city’s planning and zoning board and the Florida Department of Environmental Protection.

Lopez outlined the proposed settlement, which would allow the plaintiff to apply for a dock permit while ensuring that the city would not object to the dock's location, provided it meets regulatory requirements. Importantly, the settlement would dismiss the lawsuit with prejudice, preventing the same claims from being filed again. The city would not incur any financial costs as part of this agreement.

The commission members expressed their support for the settlement, recognizing it as a sensible resolution that balances the interests of the city and the plaintiff. A motion was made and unanimously approved, allowing the city to move forward with the settlement process.

This decision marks a proactive step by the city to resolve legal disputes while facilitating private development in a manner that aligns with regulatory standards and community interests. The commission will reconvene for a regular meeting shortly after this session.