North Dakota legislators discuss bill to regulate children's access to challenged library books

The North Dakota House Appropriations Committee convened on April 10, 2025, to discuss significant changes to library funding and regulations, particularly concerning the accessibility of certain books. A key focus of the meeting was the implications of the Children's Internet Protection Act and the E-rate funding system, which supports libraries in providing internet access.

During the session, concerns were raised about proposed last-minute changes to a bill that would alter existing policies, particularly regarding the removal of Section 6, which previously allowed for age restrictions on accessing online books. Critics argued that this change could create loopholes, allowing minors to access potentially inappropriate material through digital platforms like Libby and Hoopla. Senator Behm acknowledged the concern but emphasized a willingness to compromise, stating that the legislation aims to protect children from explicit content.

The discussion also highlighted the American Library Association's list of most challenged books, which includes titles that some legislators believe should be restricted from children's sections in libraries. However, it was clarified that these books are not necessarily located in children's areas, and the intent of the bill is not to ban them outright but to ensure they are not easily accessible to minors.

Several representatives expressed skepticism about the necessity of the proposed changes, questioning whether local libraries already have adequate measures in place to manage book selection and access. The committee acknowledged that while the goal is to safeguard children, the approach taken in the legislation may not align with existing local governance structures.

As the meeting concluded, the committee members recognized the complexity of balancing the protection of minors with the autonomy of libraries to curate their collections. The outcome of this discussion will likely influence future legislative actions regarding library policies in North Dakota.