West Haven board considers family home expansion over garage amid zoning concerns

During the recent Milford Zoning Board of Appeals meeting on March 11, 2025, a significant discussion centered around a proposed second-story addition over an existing garage, aimed at accommodating a growing family. The applicant expressed a need for more space to welcome an elderly family member who requires assistance, highlighting the personal nature of the request.

The addition, which would only extend over the garage, raised concerns among board members regarding zoning regulations. The garage, already built within a setback due to a previous variance, would further infringe upon property lines if the addition were approved. Board members debated whether the addition could be constructed over the main house instead, which would not exacerbate the existing nonconformity but could lead to a more aesthetically pleasing outcome.

Community feedback was mixed. A nearby resident voiced opposition, emphasizing that the addition would significantly alter the neighborhood's character and encroach further into the setback area. This resident had purchased their home with the understanding of the existing garage's limitations and expressed concern over the potential impact of the proposed expansion.

The board ultimately closed the hearing without a decision, indicating that further deliberation would be necessary to weigh the family's needs against community standards and zoning laws. The outcome of this application could set a precedent for future expansions in the area, making it a topic of interest for local residents and stakeholders. As the board considers its next steps, the community remains engaged, reflecting the ongoing dialogue between individual needs and collective zoning regulations in Milford.