West Florida Construction proposes dual residential projects in East Hill and North Hill districts

The City of Pensacola Architectural Review Board convened on March 20, 2025, to discuss several significant projects within the city’s historic districts. The meeting focused on new constructions and renovations aimed at preserving the architectural integrity of the area.

The first item on the agenda was a proposal for a new residence at 612 East Government Street. Summer Carter, representing West Florida Construction Group, presented plans for a 2,908 square foot structure featuring hardy lap siding, a standing seam metal roof, and vinyl windows with simulated divided lights. The board members praised the completeness of the application, noting its historical consistency. After a brief discussion, the board unanimously approved the project.

Next, the board reviewed a rehabilitation project at 819 East Jackson Street, located in the Old East Hill Preservation District. The applicant proposed replacing aluminum-clad wood windows and a storm-damaged roof with GAF timberline shingles. The discussion highlighted the condition of the existing windows, with some board members expressing a desire for more detailed assessments of their state. Ultimately, the board approved the application, with a request for further review of the window design to ensure historical accuracy.

The third item involved a replacement accessory garage at 820 North Balen Street. The applicants, Jared and Paula Willets, aimed to construct a carport with a first-floor kitchen and bath, and a second-story office space. Concerns were raised about the carport's hip roof design, which some members felt did not align with the main structure's style. The board suggested a gable roof design to better match the existing home. The motion to approve the project, contingent on the roof redesign, passed with unanimous support.

Finally, the board discussed exterior alterations to a contributing structure at 1015 North Roost Street. Architect Martin Mullen presented plans for changes that included new window openings and a rear addition with stucco treatment. While the board appreciated the overall design, some members expressed concerns about the integration of stucco with the existing materials. After a thorough discussion, the board approved the alterations, emphasizing the need for clarity on the stucco application.

Overall, the meeting underscored the board's commitment to maintaining the historical character of Pensacola while accommodating modern needs. The approved projects reflect a balance between preservation and innovation, ensuring that the city’s architectural heritage continues to thrive.