The Senate Finance and Claims Committee of the Montana Legislature convened on March 28, 2025, to discuss critical amendments to the Montana Historic Preservation Grant (MHPG) program. The meeting highlighted concerns regarding the potential negative impact of recent changes on historic preservation projects across the state.

Key discussions centered on the implications of prioritizing new grant applicants over previous awardees. Stakeholders expressed worry that this approach could jeopardize the viability of important preservation initiatives, particularly for small nonprofits and volunteer-led organizations with limited resources. The committee acknowledged that while the MHPG is a competitive grant program with finite funding, the criteria for eligibility appear inconsistent. For instance, the Friends of the Historical Museum at Fort Missoula were denied funding for a project despite not having accepted a previous grant due to unmet match requirements.

Further concerns were raised about the redefinition of historic preservation under the amended bill. Critics argued that the new focus on exterior preservation could hinder comprehensive preservation efforts, which should include modern upgrades necessary for continued public use. This shift could lead to more historic buildings remaining vacant, countering the program's goal of revitalizing communities and supporting housing and small business development.

Sarah Johnson, operations manager for the Paris Gibson Square Museum of Art, voiced strong opposition to the amended bill. She advocated for a return to the original grant format, emphasizing the museum's successful track record with past grants and its role in the Great Falls community. Johnson outlined the museum's ongoing preservation needs, including climate-controlled storage for its collection and essential building maintenance.

The committee's discussions underscored the importance of the MHPG program as a vital funding source for historic preservation in Montana. Stakeholders urged the committee to reconsider the current amendments and ensure that the program continues to support a holistic approach to preserving the state's rich historical heritage. The outcome of these discussions will significantly influence the future of historic preservation efforts in Montana.