Concerns over House Bill 547 dominated the Montana Senate Local Government meeting on March 28, 2025, as lawmakers grappled with its implications for rural communities. Critics argue that the bill threatens local control and safety by allowing Butte to exert influence over fire districts across the county, potentially undermining existing state protections.

One vocal opponent highlighted the bill's potential to strip rural areas of their ability to establish new volunteer fire districts. "If we wanted to create a new fire department in Ramsey, we would no longer be able to do that," they stated, emphasizing that the legislation could lower safety standards rather than enhance them.

The discussion also drew parallels to past actions taken by Butte, including the consolidation of police services that left rural residents waiting hours for law enforcement assistance. "This is a perfect example of how rural communities suffer when power is centralized," the opponent remarked, pointing to a history of Butte's practices that allegedly siphon resources from rural areas to benefit the city.

Further concerns were raised about the consolidation of road districts and stormwater management, which critics claim have led to inefficiencies and increased costs for rural residents. "All the people throughout the county are paying to maintain their services while Butte benefits," they argued.

As the meeting concluded, the call to vote against House Bill 547 resonated strongly among those advocating for rural interests, underscoring the ongoing tension between urban and rural governance in Montana. The outcome of this bill could significantly impact local control and safety for communities outside of Butte.