Oak Creek residents debate Buc-ee's development plans at city commission meeting

The Oak Creek Plan Commission meeting on January 28, 2025, focused on the proposed development of a Buc-ee's gas station and convenience store, sparking significant community debate. Residents expressed strong concerns about the size and impact of the project, particularly regarding a large sign and the overall aesthetic of the area.

One resident voiced her opposition, stating, "I don't want a 25-foot, big sign blinking in the middle of the night at my front door." She emphasized that many in the community feel similarly, questioning why a Texas-based company would choose to establish itself in Oak Creek, a city she described as lacking major attractions.

In contrast, another speaker defended the project, arguing that it would benefit not only Oak Creek but also the broader Southeastern Wisconsin area. He highlighted the potential for increased tax revenue, which could support local services and infrastructure. "Having a strong business base is key to small communities such as Oak Creek thriving," he stated, noting that the project could help maintain low property taxes while enhancing community services.

The discussion also touched on the specifics of the Buc-ee's development, including its size and the number of fuel pumps proposed. Some residents suggested that the company should consider a more community-friendly approach, such as reducing the number of pumps and signage to better fit the neighborhood's character.

City Administrator Andrew Vickers provided clarification on the financial aspects of the project, mentioning that the property lies within a Tax Increment District that is set to close soon. He explained that this closure would result in property tax relief for residents in the following budget year, emphasizing the city's positive track record with tax increment financing.

As the meeting concluded, it was clear that the Buc-ee's proposal has generated a mix of excitement and apprehension among Oak Creek residents, highlighting the ongoing challenge of balancing development with community values. The commission will continue to evaluate the project as it moves forward.