Residents express concerns over Buc-ee's gas station proposal in Oak Creek

Concerns over a proposed 20-pump gas station in Oak Creek took center stage during the Plan Commission meeting on March 26, 2025, as residents voiced their apprehensions about environmental impacts and community well-being.

Local residents raised critical questions about the potential blight and environmental risks associated with the gas station, particularly its proximity to the Root River and residential areas. One resident highlighted the fragility of the market, recalling how long a nearby corner remained vacant after a previous business closure. “What happens to the blight that happens when they go out of business?” they asked, emphasizing the need for careful consideration of the area’s future.

Another resident, Melinda Dobbs, expressed concerns about the environmental implications of fuel runoff, urging the commission to prioritize the community's award-winning water quality. “If there’s any kind of accident, that all goes into Lake Michigan,” she warned, advocating for a potential relocation of the gas station to a more suitable area near IKEA, which could also benefit local businesses.

The discussions underscored a broader debate about the balance between economic development and maintaining the quality of life for Oak Creek residents. While some argued that the gas station could create jobs and boost the local economy, others questioned the necessity of adding more gas stations in an already saturated market.

As the meeting concluded, the commission was left to weigh the community's concerns against the proposed benefits, with residents eagerly awaiting further discussions on the project's future. The outcome could significantly impact the character and environment of Oak Creek, making it a pivotal moment for the city.