In a recent meeting of the Newport City Zoning Board of Review, held on October 28, 2024, board members engaged in a spirited discussion regarding a petition for a second-floor deck and a third-floor balcony at a residential property. The atmosphere was charged with anticipation as board members weighed the merits of the proposal against community concerns.

Mr. Johnson, one of the board members, expressed strong support for the applicant, noting that the case presented was compelling and straightforward. He acknowledged the objections raised by Mr. Valente, a concerned neighbor, but emphasized that the proposal would likely have proceeded without much debate had it not been for the objections. Johnson highlighted his site visit, which left him feeling comfortable with the proposed changes, and reassured that the new structures would not lead to excessive noise or visual disturbances.

The discussion also touched on the potential for the property to be used as a rental or party house, a concern voiced by Valente. Johnson countered this by sharing his own experience with similar structures in his neighborhood, suggesting that fears of disruptive gatherings often do not materialize. He noted that many homeowners invest in outdoor amenities like fire pits and hot tubs, which may not see frequent use.

Another board member echoed Johnson's sentiments, expressing initial reservations about the size of the deck but ultimately agreeing that it aligned with the property's design. He pointed out that the proposed decks would be situated off private spaces rather than public areas, which could mitigate noise concerns. Additionally, the board acknowledged the applicant's willingness to address water runoff issues, a gesture that demonstrated a commitment to being good neighbors.

As the meeting drew to a close, the board unanimously voted in favor of the petition, approving it with a 5-0 tally. The decision reflects a balance between individual property rights and community concerns, showcasing the board's role in navigating these often complex discussions. With the petition approved, the applicant can now proceed with their plans, while neighbors can take comfort in the commitments made regarding environmental considerations. The meeting concluded with a sense of resolution, leaving attendees hopeful for a harmonious outcome in the neighborhood.