Residents protest borough's plan to remove 14 historic blue spruce trees
March 23, 2025 | Franklin Park, Allegheny County, Pennsylvania
This article was created by AI summarizing key points discussed. AI makes mistakes, so for full details and context, please refer to the video of the full meeting. Please report any errors so we can fix them. Report an error »
Residents of Franklin Park are rallying to save 14 mature blue spruce trees slated for removal by the borough, citing their long-standing presence and community value. During the Borough Council meeting on March 19, 2025, local homeowners expressed their concerns over a recent letter from REACH, which indicated the borough's decision to clear the trees located at the intersection of Oakleaf Lane and Reeskind Road.
Mark Puntil, a resident and former custom builder, highlighted the trees' significance, noting they have stood for over three decades and serve as a windbreak and privacy barrier for the community. He emphasized that the trees have been well-maintained, with a history of professional care costing approximately $3,000 annually. Puntil argued that their removal would negatively impact the neighborhood, particularly concerning traffic and aesthetics.
Dan Puntil, another resident and former president of the Franklin Ridge Association, echoed these sentiments, pointing out that the trees had not posed any safety hazards during their long tenure. He criticized the borough's sudden enforcement of right-of-way regulations, stating that residents were unaware of any violations until recently. He also raised concerns about perceived inconsistencies in enforcement, noting that other properties in the area have similar tree placements without repercussions.
Marissa Himmeyer, the property owner adjacent to the trees, added her voice to the discussion, emphasizing that the trees were part of the landscape when she purchased her home eight years ago. She expressed a desire to collaborate with the borough to find a solution that preserves the trees while addressing any regulatory concerns.
The residents are advocating for alternative solutions that would allow the trees to remain, demonstrating a strong community commitment to preserving their neighborhood's character. The council's decision on this matter will be closely watched, as it could set a precedent for future enforcement of right-of-way regulations and community landscaping practices.
Mark Puntil, a resident and former custom builder, highlighted the trees' significance, noting they have stood for over three decades and serve as a windbreak and privacy barrier for the community. He emphasized that the trees have been well-maintained, with a history of professional care costing approximately $3,000 annually. Puntil argued that their removal would negatively impact the neighborhood, particularly concerning traffic and aesthetics.
Dan Puntil, another resident and former president of the Franklin Ridge Association, echoed these sentiments, pointing out that the trees had not posed any safety hazards during their long tenure. He criticized the borough's sudden enforcement of right-of-way regulations, stating that residents were unaware of any violations until recently. He also raised concerns about perceived inconsistencies in enforcement, noting that other properties in the area have similar tree placements without repercussions.
Marissa Himmeyer, the property owner adjacent to the trees, added her voice to the discussion, emphasizing that the trees were part of the landscape when she purchased her home eight years ago. She expressed a desire to collaborate with the borough to find a solution that preserves the trees while addressing any regulatory concerns.
The residents are advocating for alternative solutions that would allow the trees to remain, demonstrating a strong community commitment to preserving their neighborhood's character. The council's decision on this matter will be closely watched, as it could set a precedent for future enforcement of right-of-way regulations and community landscaping practices.
View full meeting
This article is based on a recent meeting—watch the full video and explore the complete transcript for deeper insights into the discussion.
View full meeting