In a passionate plea during the San Antonio Historic Compliance and Technical Advisory Board meeting, community members voiced strong opposition to the proposed replacement of a historic clay tile roof at 507 Fir Street. The roof, deemed a significant asset due to its durability and aesthetic appeal, was removed without proper authorization, sparking concerns over the integrity of the neighborhood's historic character.

Advocates highlighted the clay tile's historical and monetary value, arguing that its replacement with a less authentic metal material would undermine the property’s legacy. "Clay roofs are a distinguishing physical aspect of lasting beauty and timeless taste," one speaker emphasized, urging the board to deny the applicant's request for substitution. They pointed out that less than 3% of homes in the historic district feature metal roofs, underscoring the uniqueness of the clay tile.

The discussion also touched on the need for consistent enforcement of historic district guidelines, referencing a nearby property that was required to reinstall its clay roof after a similar violation. Community members stressed that the property at 507 Fir is not just an income-generating rental but a structure with rich history deserving of restoration to its original state.

In closing, advocates called for accountability from the property owner and urged the board to prioritize the preservation of the neighborhood's historical fabric, stating, "We preserve before we restore, and we restore before we replace." The board's decision on this matter could set a significant precedent for future historic preservation efforts in San Antonio.