Board evaluates restoration plans for historic hotel renovation in Miami

On February 8, 2022, the Historic Preservation Board of Miami Beach convened to discuss significant renovations proposed for a historic property, focusing on the preservation of architectural features and materials. The meeting highlighted the complexities involved in balancing modern updates with the integrity of the building's historical elements.

A key topic of discussion was the condition of existing features, particularly the flooring and columns. Board members expressed concerns about the potential for undiscovered historical elements beneath the current surfaces. There was a consensus that if any remarkable features, such as a centerpiece or medallion, were found, staff should have the discretion to retain or reconstruct them. The board emphasized the importance of maintaining the building's historical narrative while accommodating necessary renovations.

Members acknowledged the challenges posed by previous renovations, which may have altered original materials. The discussion included the possibility of restoring existing terrazzo flooring and the significance of the octagonal columns, which were a condition of prior approvals. The board recognized the need for flexibility in decision-making, allowing staff to assess the condition of these elements during the renovation process.

Overall, the board expressed strong support for the proposed project, praising the design team's sensitivity to the building's historical context. The integration of accessibility features into the design was particularly noted as a positive aspect, demonstrating a thoughtful approach to modern needs without compromising the building's character.

As the meeting concluded, the board underscored the importance of collaboration with staff to ensure that any discoveries during the renovation could be addressed appropriately, allowing for a respectful balance between preservation and modernization. The discussions set the stage for ongoing evaluations as the project progresses, reflecting the community's commitment to preserving its architectural heritage while adapting to contemporary requirements.