Medical Society opposes House Bill 10 citing risks to minor patient care

The New Hampshire Legislature convened on February 22, 2025, to discuss House Bill 10, which addresses parental consent for minors seeking health care services. The meeting featured testimony from various stakeholders, highlighting significant concerns regarding the bill's implications for the physician-patient relationship and access to care for minors.

The first speaker, representing a medical society, expressed strong opposition to the bill, particularly Section 3, which mandates written parental consent before health care practitioners can provide services to minors. The speaker argued that this requirement could create barriers to timely medical treatment, especially for vulnerable youth who may fear disclosing their health issues to parents. They emphasized that such barriers could discourage minors from seeking necessary care, potentially leading to severe health consequences.

A representative, drawing from personal experience as a parent, questioned how the bill would affect routine medical processes. They described a recent situation involving their teenager's dental surgery and the need for a prescription. The representative expressed concern that the bill could complicate straightforward medical procedures by requiring additional parental consent, thus delaying treatment.

Anne Marie Banfield, a parental rights advocate, supported the bill but pointed out a critical omission regarding the protection of student data. She raised alarms about the collection and potential misuse of sensitive information by educational technology vendors, arguing that parents should have more control over their children's data. Banfield called for legislation that ensures parental consent is required before any sensitive information is shared or accessed.

Representative David Luno also addressed the committee, emphasizing the bill's statewide impact and the importance of considering the needs of all Granite Staters in the legislative process.

The meeting underscored the tension between parental rights and the need for minors to access health care without unnecessary obstacles. As discussions continue, stakeholders are urged to consider the potential consequences of House Bill 10 on the health and well-being of New Hampshire's youth.