PCSD board denies Watson Middle School charter application amid budget shortfall concerns

During the South Carolina Public Charter School District Board Meeting on March 13, 2025, significant concerns were raised regarding the financial viability and operational structure of the proposed Watson Middle School. The board discussed alarming budget inconsistencies, including unaccounted employer retirement contributions that could lead to an estimated $4.4 million shortfall over the next decade. This financial strain is projected to result in Watson Middle School operating at a deficit in eight out of its ten years.

The proposed administrative structure for the school has also come under scrutiny, with plans for two principals and six vice principals by year eight, raising questions about the efficiency of such an extensive administrative team. Additionally, the school’s focus on science, technology, engineering, and math (STEM) was called into question due to insufficient staffing in these critical areas.

A potential conflict of interest was highlighted as the facility proposed for the school is owned by the chair of the planning committee. The lease agreement could result in payments totaling $4.2 million over ten years to this individual, prompting concerns about fiduciary duty and financial oversight.

Given these deficiencies in evidence of need, location feasibility, and financial viability, the board staff recommended denying the charter application for Watson Middle School. Following a motion and a second, the board unanimously voted to deny the application, reflecting a commitment to maintaining standards for charter school establishment in accordance with the South Carolina Charter Schools Act.

In addition to the discussion on Watson Middle School, the meeting included a financial report from Nick Michael, who indicated that the district is currently operating at a net gain. As of January 31, 2025, the district reported a revenue of over $117.8 million against expenditures of approximately $117.7 million, resulting in a net gain of $90,169 for the month. The board approved this financial report, which highlighted the district's reliance on state funding, as local tax support is not available for charter schools.

The discussions during this meeting underscore the board's diligence in ensuring that charter schools meet necessary financial and operational standards, while also navigating the complexities of funding and administrative structures within the district. The denial of Watson Middle School's application serves as a reminder of the importance of accountability and transparency in educational governance.