Landmarks Commission to review Atlas Pinnacle shingle proposal for roof replacement

The Waukesha Landmarks Commission convened on March 5, 2025, to discuss various topics related to the preservation and enhancement of the city's historical sites. A key agenda item focused on a proposal for a roof replacement at a designated landmark.

The applicant presented plans to replace the existing gray 3-tab shingled roof, which was noted to be in poor condition. The proposed new roofing material is Atlas Pinnacle impact shingles in a pewter color. However, the commission highlighted that this brand has not previously received approval for use on landmark properties.

The discussion emphasized the importance of maintaining the historical integrity of the site while considering modern materials. The commission will need to review the application further to determine if the proposed shingles align with the preservation standards set for landmark buildings.

As the meeting progressed, members expressed the need for a thorough evaluation of the proposed materials to ensure they meet the city's guidelines for historical preservation. The commission plans to revisit this topic in future meetings, aiming to balance the applicant's needs with the preservation of Waukesha's architectural heritage.