In a recent meeting of the Nantucket Historic District Commission, members gathered to discuss proposed renovations for a historic property on King Street. The atmosphere was charged with a blend of enthusiasm and caution as the commission reviewed plans that included a new front door, the addition of gable hoods over the entrance, and the painting of the chimney white.

The discussion quickly turned to the chimney, a focal point of contention. While some members expressed support for the proposed white paint, others voiced strong objections, arguing that a white chimney would not be in keeping with the character of the neighborhood. Holly, a commission member, suggested that the chimney should remain its natural color, a sentiment echoed by Rob Benchley, who emphasized that white chimneys are not typical for the area.

As the conversation unfolded, the commission members debated the aesthetics of the proposed changes. The idea of shingling the portico above the front door was also brought up, with several members agreeing that this would enhance the property’s historical integrity. The proposed Hamilton blue for the shutters received approval, indicating a consensus on at least one aspect of the renovation.

Ultimately, the commission voted on the proposal, with the motion to approve the renovations passing with a majority. However, the painted chimney was not included in the approval, leaving the door open for the homeowners to return with a revised plan. The meeting concluded with a sense of progress, as members recognized the importance of balancing modern updates with the preservation of Nantucket's historic charm.

As the commission continues to navigate these discussions, the outcome of this renovation serves as a reminder of the delicate dance between innovation and tradition in preserving the unique character of Nantucket.