The HDC Sign Advisory Committee meeting on March 4, 2025, sparked significant discussion regarding signage for local businesses, particularly focusing on a proposed sign for a new upstairs yoga studio at 53 Main Street. The committee members expressed a mix of support and concern over the design and placement of the sign, which aims to enhance visibility for the first-year business.

The proposal includes an 18 by 40-inch double-sided hanging sign, intended to be positioned higher than the existing signs for neighboring businesses to ensure it is easily seen from both directions on the street. Business owner Deborah Kessler emphasized the importance of visibility for attracting customers, stating, "It is super important for us to have some visible sign that people are better aware."

However, committee members raised several objections. Mark voiced concerns about the sign's alignment with existing signage, suggesting that it should match the bracket height of the adjacent business to maintain architectural consistency. He also questioned the sign's color scheme, describing it as "not very traditional" for the area. Kevin echoed these sentiments, arguing against the addition of a third sign for the building, which he felt was unnecessary given the existing signage.

Despite the pushback, some members acknowledged the need for signage for upstairs businesses, recognizing that visibility is crucial for their success. The committee ultimately agreed to further review the proposal, weighing the balance between maintaining Nantucket's historic aesthetic and supporting local businesses.

As discussions continue, the outcome of this proposal could set a precedent for future signage applications in the area, highlighting the ongoing challenge of blending modern business needs with traditional community standards.