During the recent Plymouth Board of Health meeting held on September 18, 2024, a unique request was presented regarding the keeping of a rooster named Henry at 31 James Court Circle. The owner, Elizabeth, sought a variance from town regulations that typically prohibit roosters, citing Henry as her emotional support animal.

Elizabeth shared her experience with Henry, explaining that he had been part of her family for nearly six years without any prior complaints from neighbors. She noted that Henry is kept indoors until after 9 AM and is brought back inside before dark to minimize noise disturbances. Despite a recent complaint about his crowing, Elizabeth argued that the sounds made by Henry are minimal compared to other neighborhood noises, including barking dogs and lawn maintenance activities.

The board acknowledged the town's regulations against roosters but also recognized the emotional support aspect of Henry's presence in Elizabeth's life. The discussion included a review of past cases where similar requests had been granted, emphasizing the need to balance community regulations with individual needs.

Several neighbors voiced their support for Henry, with one resident, William Stone, expressing that Henry's crowing brings joy and a sense of life to the community. Stone highlighted the care that Elizabeth and her family provide to Henry and the hens, suggesting that the rooster's presence is a positive aspect of their neighborhood.

The board considered the implications of granting the variance, noting that it could set a precedent for future requests. They discussed potential limitations, such as the use of a crow collar to reduce noise when Henry is outside.

As the meeting concluded, the board members were tasked with weighing the community's concerns against the emotional support needs of Elizabeth. The outcome of this request could influence how similar cases are handled in the future, reflecting the ongoing dialogue between individual rights and community standards in Plymouth.