Historic window renovation plan for significant Santa Fe property approved

The Historic District Review Board of Santa Fe convened on February 25, 2025, to discuss a significant proposal involving the replacement and restoration of windows in a historic building. The meeting focused on the applicant's request to replace several windows while restoring others, raising questions about compliance with city preservation standards.

The proposal includes replacing Windows 2, 5, 6, and 7 with aluminum-clad windows featuring simulated divided lights. In contrast, the applicant seeks to restore Windows 1, 3, 4, and 8, repainting them white and adding storm sashes. However, the request to replace Window 2 contradicts the window assessment, which recommended repair instead. Similarly, the assessment suggested replacing Window 4, while the applicant proposed to repair it.

City staff indicated that the exception criteria for the proposed changes have been met, recommending approval of the application as it aligns with the city's design standards. However, board members expressed concerns regarding the replacement of historic windows and the use of simulated divided lights instead of true divided lights, which are typically preferred for significant structures.

The applicant clarified that the proposed aluminum-clad wood windows would mimic the original steel windows in design and appearance, maintaining the same number of lights and profiles. This clarification aimed to address board members' concerns about the integrity of the historic structure.

As the meeting progressed, board members sought further clarification on the specifics of the proposal and the window assessment's recommendations. The discussion highlighted the delicate balance between modern updates and the preservation of historic character in Santa Fe's architectural landscape.

The board will continue to deliberate on the application, considering both the applicant's intentions and the city's preservation guidelines. The outcome of this proposal could set a precedent for future renovations in the historic district, emphasizing the importance of maintaining the integrity of significant buildings while accommodating necessary updates.