Germantown planning commission approves controversial Starbucks drive-thru project

The Germantown Planning Commission meeting on February 4, 2025, focused primarily on the proposed development of a new Starbucks location within a shopping center. The discussion highlighted concerns regarding traffic flow and pedestrian access, ultimately leading to a vote on the project.

Commissioner Levy raised significant concerns about car queuing in the driveway, suggesting that while Starbucks and the landlord had considered the issue, it remained a core problem. He expressed willingness to approve the project despite these concerns, emphasizing that other issues discussed were relatively minor. Commissioner Sloan echoed Levy's sentiments, arguing that the concerns were overstated and that the project had been well-planned.

Several commissioners noted the importance of the Starbucks location, suggesting it would enhance the shopping center's appeal and branding. Commissioner Bacon highlighted the synergy created by the new development alongside existing businesses like Whole Foods and Trader Joe's. He also supported the parking reduction proposed for the site, citing a lack of pedestrian traffic in the area.

However, not all commissioners were in favor. Commissioner Jacobs voiced concerns about pedestrian access, particularly for individuals using the nearby bus stop. He argued that the lack of safe access could pose a public safety issue. Alderman Salvaggio also expressed similar concerns, stating that his vote against the project was based on safety considerations rather than opposition to the development itself.

Despite the dissenting opinions, the majority of commissioners ultimately voted in favor of the Starbucks project, viewing it as a positive addition to the community. The approval reflects a broader commitment to smart growth principles, even as discussions about pedestrian safety and traffic management continue to be relevant in future developments.