Aiken's historic barns are at the center of a heated debate as residents urge the City Council to designate them as contributing structures to preserve their architectural and cultural significance. During the February 10, 2025, council meeting, community members passionately argued for the protection of the Hitchcock Barns and Whitney Barns, emphasizing their unique construction and historical ties to Aiken's equestrian heritage.

Valerie Roble, a South Aiken resident, warned council members against the dangers of not designating these barns as contributing structures. "If you decide to make this a non-contributing structure, you are opening a slippery slope," she cautioned, highlighting the potential for future developments to undermine the historic character of the district. Roble stressed the importance of maintaining Aiken's unique history, particularly in the Horse District, which she believes is unparalleled in the United States.

Steve Kisner, a local builder, echoed these sentiments, noting that preserving the barns aligns with the reasons many people choose to retire in Aiken. "People come here because they like what is preserved here," he stated, emphasizing the community's charm and friendly atmosphere.

The discussions reflect a broader concern among residents about the preservation of Aiken's historic identity amidst modern development pressures. As the council weighs its options, the community remains vigilant, advocating for a decision that honors the city's rich heritage and ensures that these historic structures endure for future generations.