Bayonne Council debates historic designation for closed Saint Andrew Church amid parish objections

The Bayonne City Council meeting on February 1, 2025, focused on the contentious issue of designating Saint Andrew the Apostle Church as a historic landmark. The discussion highlighted the financial struggles of the parish and the implications of such a designation.

Patrick Castello, a trustee of the parish, expressed strong opposition to the historic designation, arguing that it would not lead to the restoration of the church and would instead result in costly litigation for both the parish and the city. He emphasized that the parish has already faced significant financial challenges, including failed attempts to sell the church property due to zoning issues. Castello stated that the church's closure was a necessary decision driven by declining attendance and financial viability, asserting that the parish could not afford to maintain the building.

Other parishioners echoed Castello's sentiments, arguing that the church's historical significance should not overshadow the practical financial realities facing the parish. They pointed out that the parish had received substantial funds from the sale of the school and convent but still faced a significant deficit in necessary repairs for both churches.

In contrast, supporters of the historic designation argued for the cultural and architectural importance of the church. They highlighted the church's unique stained glass windows and its role as a community landmark. Some speakers emphasized the need to preserve the church as a testament to the community's history and heritage.

Father Philip Sanders, the pastor of Blessed Miriam Teresa Parish, reiterated the financial difficulties faced by the parish, stating that the church's closure was a painful but necessary decision. He urged the council to consider the burden that a historic designation would place on the already struggling parish.

The meeting concluded with a call for the council to weigh the historical significance of the church against the financial realities of maintaining it. The council's decision on the historic designation will have lasting implications for the parish and the community, as they navigate the balance between preserving history and addressing current financial challenges.