The Nantucket Zoning Board of Appeals (ZBA) held a special meeting on January 24, 2025, where critical discussions centered on the implications of new housing developments and their potential environmental impacts. A key concern raised was the need for thorough engagement from developers regarding the safety and sustainability of their projects, particularly in light of local environmental vulnerabilities.

Board member Murphy expressed frustration over the lack of collaboration from the applicant team, emphasizing that a refusal to engage or invest in independent peer reviews undermines the decision-making process. He highlighted the importance of finding a middle ground to avoid a standoff, which could hinder progress on addressing Nantucket's housing crisis.

Ayesha Khan, a year-round resident and co-founder of the Nantucket PFAS Action Group, voiced her concerns about the proposed development's compliance with state regulations. While acknowledging the necessity for housing, she stressed that compliance does not equate to safety, particularly given Nantucket's reliance on a sole aquifer. Khan warned that high-density developments could exacerbate pollution risks, especially with impervious surfaces that hinder natural water filtration.

Khan urged the ZBA to prioritize community safety over developer profits, advocating for reduced impervious surfaces and enhanced stormwater management. She called for the board to challenge the information presented by developers and seek independent evaluations to ensure that community interests are safeguarded.

The discussions at this meeting underscore the ZBA's critical role in balancing development needs with environmental protection, as Nantucket navigates its housing challenges while safeguarding its unique ecosystem. The board's commitment to rigorous oversight will be essential in shaping sustainable growth for the community.