Carbon pricing took center stage during the New Hampshire House Science, Technology and Energy Committee meeting on January 21, 2025, as lawmakers debated the implications of proposed legislation. The discussion highlighted a significant divide among representatives regarding the potential impact of carbon pricing on the state's economy and energy costs.

Chairman Vos opened the conversation by recalling a previous hearing on carbon pricing from 2019, where House Bill 735 faced considerable opposition due to its hefty price tag of $795 million. He noted that the bill was ultimately tabled without a full debate on the House floor. Vos expressed skepticism about the current support for carbon pricing, particularly in light of low voter turnout in Merrimack, where he argued that climate change is not a top priority for residents.

In contrast, Representative Wendy Thomas, also from Merrimack, countered Vos's claims by emphasizing that constituents are urging lawmakers to address carbon pricing as a pressing issue. She framed the proposal not as a tax on energy, but rather as a tax on polluters, aimed at fostering climate protections. Thomas pointed to successful carbon pricing models in Canada, where residents receive rebates, suggesting that New Hampshire could benefit similarly.

The debate intensified as Representative Summers chimed in, noting that while some constituents advocate for carbon pricing, many others are more concerned about rising energy costs. This sentiment reflects a broader tension between environmental initiatives and economic concerns, as lawmakers grapple with the potential consequences of carbon pricing on fuel and electricity rates.

As the committee continues to deliberate, the future of carbon pricing legislation remains uncertain, with representatives divided on its necessity and feasibility. The outcome could significantly influence New Hampshire's approach to climate change and energy policy in the coming years.