During the Seattle City Council Public Safety Committee meeting on December 10, 2024, significant concerns were raised regarding the use of less-lethal weapons by the Seattle Police Department (SPD) and the implications for public safety and accountability. The discussions highlighted the ongoing tension between maintaining public order and protecting citizens' rights, particularly in the wake of past incidents involving police conduct during protests.

Valerie Schlorette, a representative from District 2, emphasized the need for accountability in police actions, particularly referencing the SPD's handling of the George Floyd protests in 2020. She criticized the vagueness of the proposed legislation, arguing that it fails to ensure proper accountability for officers using potentially harmful weapons. Schlorette pointed out that despite the city’s efforts to comply with a federal consent decree, there are still significant concerns about police accountability and the potential for abuse of power.

Lindsay Burgess, another speaker, echoed these sentiments, opposing the use of blast walls and other less-lethal weapons. She raised alarms about the risks associated with these tools, which can cause serious injuries and infringe on individuals' First Amendment rights. Burgess called for a postponement of the vote on the legislation to allow for greater public input and transparency, stressing that the potential for misuse could further erode public trust in law enforcement.

Hamish, a private citizen from District 5, also expressed concerns about the lack of clarity in the proposed legislation regarding exceptions for the use of less-lethal weapons. He warned that the current wording could lead to situations similar to those experienced during the protests of 2020, which resulted in numerous complaints and significant financial settlements against the city. Hamish urged the council to seek more public input before making substantial changes to the legislation.

The meeting underscored a critical moment for Seattle as it navigates the balance between ensuring public safety and upholding civil rights. The discussions reflect a broader societal concern about police practices and accountability, particularly in the context of recent movements advocating for reform. As the council considers the proposed legislation, the call for public hearings and increased transparency may shape the future of policing in Seattle, ensuring that community voices are heard in the decision-making process.