A powerful testimony at the Virginia Behavioral Health Subcommittee meeting on January 16, 2025, highlighted urgent concerns over medical consent and women's reproductive rights. Karen Collins, a Caroline resident, shared her harrowing experience of undergoing a surgical procedure that resulted in the removal of her only remaining ovary without her consent.

Collins recounted how she had consented to a diagnostic laparoscopy and a possible appendectomy in 2018, only to wake up to the devastating news that her ovary had been removed. This unexpected surgery not only rendered her sterile but also thrust her into early menopause at just 37 years old. "My doctor took something from my body without my permission, betrayed my trust, and violated his oath," Collins stated, emphasizing the emotional and physical toll the incident has had on her life and family.

Her case is not an isolated incident. Collins revealed that many women across the country have faced similar violations, often without recourse. She pointed to a recent case in Chesapeake involving a doctor who had numerous victims, highlighting a troubling pattern of unnecessary surgeries performed without proper consent, particularly affecting minority and economically disadvantaged women.

Despite her efforts to seek justice through the legal system, Collins faced significant barriers, including difficulty finding legal representation willing to take on medical malpractice cases. Ultimately, her case was dismissed in court, with the jury siding with the doctor based on vague consent language that allowed for unforeseen procedures.

Collins urged the committee to take action, advocating for stronger protections for women against unnecessary surgeries. She expressed disappointment that a more specific bill proposed last year did not pass, but acknowledged that a companion bill in the Senate received bipartisan support. "Doctors should not have free reign on women's bodies based on what they deem to be in her best interest," she asserted, calling for legislation that ensures women retain control over their reproductive health decisions.

The meeting underscored the critical need for reform in medical consent practices, particularly regarding surgeries that can have life-altering consequences for women. As discussions continue, advocates like Collins remain hopeful for meaningful change that prioritizes patient autonomy and accountability in the medical field.