Payson Town Council is facing significant scrutiny following a controversial decision to appoint Charlie Sarafin as interim town manager without a transparent selection process. During the January 8, 2025, meeting, council members expressed concerns over the lack of public discussion and the implications of appointing a friend of the current administration to the role.

Council members highlighted the importance of transparency and due process in filling key positions, referencing a previous instance when a thorough selection process was conducted to appoint a new council member. Critics of the current decision argue that bypassing this process undermines community trust and could lead to further division within the town.

One council member passionately articulated their concerns, drawing parallels between Sarafin's appointment and a cautionary tale about trust and betrayal. They emphasized that the council has capable deputy town managers who could serve in the interim role until a permanent manager is hired, suggesting that the decision to appoint Sarafin was unnecessary and detrimental to the community.

The council's decision has sparked a broader conversation about governance and accountability in Payson. As the council prepares to move forward, the implications of this appointment and the call for a more transparent process remain at the forefront of community discussions. The council is expected to continue deliberating on the best path forward, with a focus on restoring trust and ensuring that the needs of Payson residents are prioritized.