Syracuse's Landmark Preservation Board convened on January 9, 2025, to discuss a significant proposal that could reshape a historic neighborhood. The meeting centered around a plan to replace an existing garage at 100 Windsor Place with a new two-and-a-half car garage, which will include a one-bedroom accessory dwelling unit (ADU) above it.

The current garage has been plagued by flooding issues, rendering it unusable during rainstorms. The proposed design aims to address these drainage problems while providing adequate storage for vehicles and equipment, including a tractor. The new structure is intended to be closer to the main house, creating a breezeway connection and enhancing the overall aesthetic of the property.

The design incorporates elements that reflect the existing home, such as matching brick and window styles, while also introducing landscaping to buffer the structure from neighboring properties. The garage will feature three new windows and a separate entry for the ADU, which is designed to be under the 800 square foot threshold, measuring 797 square feet.

Support for the project was voiced by community members who praised the owners for their investment in the property and the thoughtful design choices. They highlighted the importance of maintaining the character of the neighborhood while accommodating modern needs.

However, opposition emerged from residents concerned about the impact on the historic character of Berkeley Park. One resident argued that the proposed structure would detract from the neighborhood's aesthetic, emphasizing that the area is known for its classic colonial revival architecture and formal landscapes. They expressed worries about the scale of the new building, which they believe does not align with the existing structures in the area.

The board engaged in a thorough discussion, addressing concerns about privacy, the absence of windows on one side of the garage, and the overall compatibility of the new construction with the historic district's guidelines. The meeting concluded with a commitment to further evaluate the proposal, ensuring that any developments respect the unique character of Berkeley Park while addressing the needs of its residents.

As the board deliberates, the outcome of this proposal will be closely watched, as it holds implications for the preservation of Syracuse's historic neighborhoods amidst evolving community needs.