During the recent Development Review Board meeting on January 9, 2025, in Scottsdale, community members voiced strong opinions regarding a proposed housing project on Oak Street, highlighting concerns about density, traffic, and neighborhood character.

One resident raised alarms about the project's density, claiming it would be the most congested development in Scottsdale, with a density seven times greater than nearby Sherwood Heights. This resident argued that the proposed 94 units on just nine acres would significantly increase traffic on Oak Street, which is already considered precarious. They emphasized that many units would lack direct road access, further complicating traffic flow. Additionally, they criticized the notification process for the hearing, stating that they and their neighbors were not adequately informed, which they believed violated city rules.

In contrast, another speaker, Ed Hadley, expressed support for the project, emphasizing the need for more affordable housing in Scottsdale. He noted that many employees commute long distances from neighboring areas, and the new development could help alleviate this issue by providing living spaces closer to work. Hadley highlighted the importance of building more housing options for families in the community.

Thomas O'Leary, another resident, urged the board to reject the Oak Street application, arguing that it would disrupt the existing neighborhood's character and traffic patterns. He pointed out that Oak Street is a low-traffic area with limited development, and he questioned the appropriateness of such a dense project in that context.

The discussions at the meeting reflect a broader tension in Scottsdale between the need for increased housing and the preservation of neighborhood character. As the city continues to grow, balancing these competing interests will be crucial for maintaining community cohesion and addressing housing demands. The Development Review Board will need to consider these diverse perspectives as they move forward with their decision-making process.